The Green Murder (?) Case (Page Six)

 

He said that she “not only gave Green a glimpse of the treasured archive; she also asked for his help in transferring various papers to her solicitor’s office. ‘Richard told me that he had physically moved them,’ Edwards said. ‘so his knowledge was really quite dangerous.’” He called Green

            “the biggest figure standing in the way” of the Christie’s auction, since he had seen some of the papers and could testify that Dame Jean had intended to donate them to the British Library. Soon after the sale was announced, Edwards said, he and Green had learned that Charles Foley, Sir Arthur’s great-nephew, and two of Foley’s cousins were behind the sale. But neither he nor Green could understand how these distant heirs had legally obtained control of the archive. “All we were clear about was that there was a scam and that, clearly, someone was robbing stuff that should go to the British Library,” Edwards said. He added, “This was not a hypothesis–it was quite certain in our own minds.”

            Edwards told Grann that he was sure that Green had been murdered. He said that autoerotic asphyxiation, as suggested by the coroner, was unlikely, as there was no evidence that Green was engaged in any sort of sexual activity at the time of his death. “He added that garroting is typically a brutal method of execution– ‘a method of murder which a skilled professional would use.’” Also, Edwards said that “Green had no known history of depression”; the day before he died he made plans to take a vacation in Italy with a friend the following week; he was garroted with a shoelace but only wore slip-on shoes; a compulsive note-taker such as Green would surely have left a suicide note; and, finally, the partly empty bottle of gin was evidence that someone else had been in the room, since Green had drunk wine at dinner and would never have followed it with gin.

            Edwards warned Grann: “Please be careful. I don’t want to see you garroted, like poor Richard.” He then named the mysterious American, describing him as “one of Donald Rumsfeld’s pals.”

Grann flew to Washington, D.C., and tracked the American down. They met at Timberlake’s Pub near DuPont Circle. The American said that he was a long-time member of the Baker Street Irregulars and had represented Doyle’s literary estate in America. Grann says, “It is his main job, though, that has given him a slightly menacing air–at least in the minds of Green’s friends. He works for the Pentagon in a high-ranking post that deals with clandestine operations.” He asked that Grann not reveal his name in the article, because “I don’t think a lot of people at the Pentagon would understand my fascination with a literary character.” Grann respects the American’s desire for anonymity in the article, but he gives a detailed description of him and completely blows his cover by revealing that his Baker Street Irregulars name is “Rodger Prescott of evil memory,” after the American counterfeiter in “The Adventure of the Three Garridebs.” One has only to visit the Baker Street Irregulars web site to discover “Rodger Prescott’s” real name. At the request of our Program Director, Bob Robinson, who is also a member of the Baker Street Irregulars, I will not reveal it here; Bob says that this person is well-liked and respected by the BSI members. Anyway, the American told Grann that he and Green had been collaborators on several Sherlockian projects, but that they had had a falling-out in the early1990s when Jean Conan Doyle saw something in print by Green that caused her to believe that Green was not as great an admirer of her father as he had claimed to be and broke off her friendship with Green. The American claimed to Grann that “Because I was Jean’s representative, I got caught in the middle of it.” A friend of Green’s, however, had told Grann that “the American played on Dame Jean’s sensitivities about her father’s reputation and seized upon some of Green’s candid words, which had never upset her before, then ‘twisted’ them like ‘a screw.’” The American told Grann that he had not seen or spoken to Green for more than a year; he admitted that he was in London the night Green died, but he had an alibi: he and his wife were on a Jack the Ripper walking tour. The American turned out to be an admirer of Green’s; he told Grann that a multimedia lecture Green gave on The Hound of the Baskervilles at the University of Minnesota three years

earlier was “dazzling.” The American also told Grann that he started writing a history of the Baker Street Irregulars and Sherlockian scholarship in 1988. “‘I thought if I searched pretty assiduously I’d find enough material to do a single hundred-and-fifty-page volume,’ he said. ‘I’ve now done five volumes for more than fifteen hundred pages, and I’ve only gotten up to 1950. . . . It’s been a slippery slope into madness and obsession.”  Grann says: “As he sat up in his chair and his eyes brightened, I realized I was talking not to Green’s Moriarty but to his soulmate.”

next_md_wht_010